On 29 September 2026, the bioclimatic school project by the engineering consultancy ODETEC won the first edition of the Eurovent Award for the best sizing of certified HVAC-R equipment. Featured amongst the categories of the 7th CFP and ICO High-Performance Engineering Awards, organised as part of the Interclima trade fair, the Eurovent Award aims to recognise projects that prioritise data accuracy, performance and sustainability when sizing certified HVAC-R equipment. Eurovent Certification spoke to Yann Darbilly, chairman and co-founder of ODETEC, to discuss the project, the award and the importance of verified data during the selection and sizing of HVAC-R products.
Yann: ODETEC is a multi-disciplinary engineering consultancy founded in 2007 in Périgueux. The company was founded with a focus on fluid systems and climate engineering. It subsequently expanded its scope of expertise to cover all disciplines within a project: structural engineering, thermal engineering, electrical engineering, acoustics and environmental quality. We now have nearly 70 staff across seven offices in France. We deliver around fifty projects a year for public and private clients across all sectors, including education, healthcare, the service sector, industry, sport and culture. Having all these skills in-house, with 43 OPQIBI accreditations, including 7 RGE, enables us to guarantee technical consistency across all disciplines and to ensure the actual performance of the buildings we design. Our role is to provide architects and clients with the means to construct carbon-neutral buildings that are cost-effective to run and designed to last.
ODETEC has been a mission-driven company since 2023. Our purpose is enshrined in our articles of association: to promote sustainable engineering in collaboration with all stakeholders, for the benefit of current and future generations. The B Corp certification we were awarded in October 2026 is part of this same approach. In practice, this translates into a simple rule for every project: passive measures before active ones; the most energy-efficient solution first, followed by the sizing of systems once requirements have been reduced.
Yann: The school complex in Saint-Laurent-sur-Manoire, in the Dordogne, brings together several classrooms and a school canteen serving between 140 and 160 meals a day on a single site. The client is the municipality of Boulazac Isle Manoire. We designed this project with the architect Bernard Chinours, from the practice Souvenir d’un futur, on a challenging site: a village centre, a 17th-century château and a listed Romanesque church right next door. The brief called for a net-positive energy building, meeting E4C1 level of the E+C- label, with genuine summer comfort.
When aiming for positive energy, it is vital not to fight the wrong battle. Before getting into the technical details, we pushed the envelope as far as possible. Energy-efficient systems come next. The challenge we set ourselves right from the design competition stage was to rely on calculations rather than mere intentions: to demonstrate from the initial sketch that the objective was achievable, then to verify this through measurement once the building was completed.
The approach is therefore bioclimatic above all else. The layout and orientation are tailored to the site. The circulation spaces are designed as thermal airlocks that store heat in a heat-storing concrete wall. The building envelope combines solid stone on the ground floor with a timber frame on the upper floor. All classrooms are fitted with adjustable sunshades. The systems complement this: a 63 kW reversible water-to-water geothermal heat pump powered by six 200-metre probes, low-temperature hot-water-only emitters, cooling provided solely by the cooling coils of the dual-flow air handling units, and 40 kWp of photovoltaic panels integrated into the roof. We specified Eurovent-certified equipment for both the air-handling units and the heat pump, in order to rely on verified and comparable performance data. The building was completed in the summer of 2025. Its first summer of operation coincided with the heatwave of June 2026, providing a real-world test of the design. The real challenge was not the technology involved, but the building’s bioclimatic design.
Yann: Our method is a continuous process, from the design competition to commissioning. Each stage refines the previous one using verifiable data.
During the design competition, we carried out a comprehensive E+C- calculation using software certified by the CSTB. This enabled us to commit to the E4C1 level and to determine the required photovoltaic area with confidence. During the preliminary design phase, we carried out a dynamic thermal simulation using Pléiades, with a ‘hot summer’ weather file rather than an average one, and using real occupancy scenarios. This simulation established the hierarchy between passive and active systems and quantified the residual cooling requirement. At the tender stage, the tender documents (CCTP) finalised the assumptions: basic outdoor conditions, indoor setpoints, overshoot rules, and a room-by-room heat balance in accordance with the NF EN 12831 standard, subject to our approval. Above all, they stipulated that Eurovent-certified equipment must be used for both the heat pump and the air-handling units, with quantified performance targets: COP, SCOP, EER, SEER and 81 per cent heat recovery efficiency.
For us, certification is a contractual prerequisite. It guarantees that the performance stated has been measured according to a common standard. It also enables us to verify a contractor’s tender without having to recalculate the system specifications. The final selection of the heat pump, based on the project’s actual operating conditions, matches the specified values exactly. As for the ground source, nothing was assumed: a thermal response test validated the site’s capacity before the installation of the ground-source heat exchanger array.
Sizing also means knowing when to compromise. Geothermal energy had been envisaged right from the design competition stage for two purposes: heating and passive cooling via geocooling. Modelling of the ground-source heat exchanger field showed that geocooling would only have reduced temperatures for around ten days a year. This represented a significant over-investment for a marginal benefit. We therefore opted for a high-performance reversible heat pump certified by Eurovent, with cooling provided by the cooling coils in the air-handling units. Following the same logic, the heating capacity evolved over the course of the studies, from an initial estimate during the design competition to 63 kW in the final selection. We deliberately retained a 30 kW electric backup to avoid oversizing the geothermal system due to just a few peak hours per year.
Yann: The first challenge was to maintain the low-carbon ambition whilst meeting regulatory requirements. In the competition, the partition walls between classrooms were planned as timber-frame structures filled with earth. Discussions with the building control authority led us to revert to a masonry solution. We accepted this compromise because it preserved thermal mass, which is key to summer comfort.
The second challenge was to integrate photovoltaic panels within the boundaries of a listed building. The surface area was reduced from 260 to 220 m², with higher-efficiency panels integrated into the roof structure rather than laid on top. The E4 rating was maintained.
The third challenge related to the system itself. A reversible geothermal system requires precise hydraulics and controls using high-performance equipment. We specified an electromagnetic meter for the glycol circuit, as ultrasonic meters are not suitable for this application. We incorporated condenser protection in cooling mode. We adjusted the functional analysis following the initial field trials.
The fourth challenge was unforeseen. The heatwave of June 2026, with daytime temperatures of 39 to 42 °C and night-time temperatures above 20 °C, exceeded the assumptions made in the simulation. It replicated the climate scenario predicted for 2050. It also revealed that the unused loft space was overheating, despite ventilation being in compliance with regulations. We have drawn two key lessons from this for our future projects: to provide thermal mass in the exposed upper storeys and to ventilate the loft space beyond the strict minimum.
In all cases, the method remained the same: simulate to anticipate, review each construction specification and measure to correct. As our HVAC engineer says, we did not seek cutting-edge innovation in any equipment. We looked for high-performance, tried-and-tested equipment, because in a school, reliability comes first.
Yann: The certification played a role at three stages. During the design phase, it provided a common basis for the design office, the installer and the manufacturer. The performance figures set out in the technical specifications are certified values. The selected Aermec heat pump and the France Air units incorporated these values exactly as they stood in their selection sheets. The heat exchanger’s 81 per cent heat recovery efficiency, Eurovent-certified, was also the figure used in the regulatory calculations. From the calculations through to the specifications and on to the installed equipment, the process is consistent from start to finish.
In operation, this consistency allows measurements to be interpreted with confidence. During the heatwave week of 22 to 27 June 2026, the centralised technical management system recorded indoor temperatures of 22 to 25 °C on the ground floor whilst it was 39 to 42 °C outside. This represents a difference of approximately 15 °C without continuous air conditioning. The classrooms on the upper floor, which have a lighter building envelope, remained between 26 and 28 °C. When active cooling was activated, it brought the supply air temperature down to 19 °C. The headteacher confirmed to us that the ground-floor rooms did not exceed 26 °C. The school continued to operate normally whilst on red alert. It even welcomed children from a neighbouring, older school into its cooled school canteen. Whilst certain ranges of air-to-water heat pumps approach their operating limits when the outside temperature exceeds 40 °C, the geothermal source remained stable.
For the long term, we have put the right conditions in place rather than promising a specific result: commissioning by the manufacturer, certified energy meters, separate electricity metering for the heat pump, exposed ventilation systems that are accessible for maintenance, and centralised technical management with data archiving and alerts. It is this instrumentation that has made the feedback from the first summer possible. It is this that will enable us to confirm the seasonal performance over the long term.
Yann: To design consultancies, we would first advise reducing the load requirement before selecting the unit. Next, to run simulations based on actual climate data rather than average conditions: June 2026 exceeded even our ‘hot summer’ weather database. Finally, to size the system to the actual demand rather than the peak. A backup system for a few hours a year costs less than an oversized geothermal system running all year round.
To installers, we’d advise providing calculation notes that are easy to follow, with the assumptions stated at the top of each document and the method clearly indicated. This is what makes the approval process useful and ensures rapid commissioning.
Project owners should include the certification in the contract. It protects them just as much as it protects their design consultancy. We would also advise them to invest in metering. Certified meters and a monitoring system that archives data represent a very small part of the budget. Yet this is the only way to know whether the building is delivering on its promises. And, of course, to get the users on board. An energy-efficient building that its occupants do not understand becomes an adversary. Explaining when to close the windows, how to position the sunshades or why to let thermal inertia take effect is part of the design process. This also applies to maintenance staff: they must learn to manage a building during a heatwave, not just a heating system.
Yann: This award recognises an entry based on measurements rather than intentions. We presented the entire process, from the competition brief to the first operational data collected during a heatwave. It is this consistency that has been recognised. The award shines a light on the whole project team, who designed and oversaw this project from the competition stage right through to handover. It also highlights a client organisation that stayed the course despite a change in leadership.
Finally, it conveys a message that is important to us. Certified performance is not the preserve of large-scale programmes. A modest-sized school in a town in the Dordogne can be energy-positive, low-carbon and remain comfortable when it’s over 40 °C outside. The real secret of this building is common sense: protecting oneself from the sun, storing cool air and, when that is no longer enough, adding a little active equipment. Schools are safe havens for children, not all of whom live in homes with good thermal performance. This is what we owe to future generations.
The bioclimatic school project has rightly won the first Eurovent Trophy, demonstrating that thoughtful design, backed by verified performance, enables the creation of sustainable buildings offering indoor comfort all year round, even in the most extreme heatwave conditions. Congratulations once again to Yann and the whole team at ODETEC, and thank you to everyone who took part in the Eurovent Award recognising the best sizing of certified HVAC-R equipment.
Find out more about the CFP and ICO Performance Engineering Awards